- 20 years old – (LoA West Virginia / HiA Bradenton)
- 2nd round – 2014
- Keller missed most of 2015 with forearm issues, but returns to the OAS circle after a terrific 2016. TPS tapped Keller during his pro debut in 2014 with the GCL Pirates, scoring a .085 metric. The Pirates rewarding Keller with a late start at HiA Bradenton where he pitched six shutout innings with 7 strikeouts and only 1 walk. That ratio was about par for the 124.1 innings at LoA West Virginia, paralleling to a 7.28 K/BB ratio. Many scouts rave about Keller’s control over his command, exciting news for a kid only 3 seasons removed from high school. Keller was the Pirates Minor League Pitcher of the Year.
- 22 years old – (LoA West Virginia / HiA Bradenton)
- 6th round – 2015
- Brubaker was also challenged with a promotion to HiA Bradenton mid-season, and endured a roller-coaster ride. The took the ball in the Florida State League Championship and pitched his first scoreless HiA outing that secured the FSL title for the Marauders.
- 22 years old – (LoA West Virginia)
- 10th round – 2015
- Sendelbach started his first full season with West Virginia as hot as any Pirate minor league pitcher. In five April starts, Sendelbach threw 27.1 innings allowing 4 earned runs, 3 walks and 14 strikeouts. He then battled inconsistencies for the rest of the season, especially an increase in his flyball rate. He has a way to go to reach a possible ceiling as a back-end starter.
- 24 years old – (HiA Bradenton)
- 27th round – 2014
- Prior to the 2016 season, I placed Coley “Just Off the Scope.” He led Bradenton with 12 wins and 139.1 innings this past season, finishing with a 1.33 WHIP.
- 22 years old – (LoA West Virginia)
- 9th round – 2015
- Helton slides into the final slot with an outstanding month of August. In five starts, Helton posted a 2.57 ERA, allowing eight earned runs over 28 innings.
- 23 years old – (LoA West Virginia / HiA Bradenton)
- 39th round – 2015
- 22 years old – (LoA West Virginia)
- 27th round – 2014
- 21 years old – (Short-Season West Virginia / LoA West Virginia)
- 15th round – 2015